One Fish: Getting The Stink Off - The Fisherman

One Fish: Getting The Stink Off

ice fish
A typical holdover schoolie, pulled across skim ice.

Back before the internet ruined (nearly) every holdover striper spot in New England, I discovered one that was – at the time – pretty much completely unknown. The striper fishery was very different then, in that there were several healthy year classes of schoolies and as a result of this, most of the fish we caught there were under 25 inches. So it was a good spot to go every few weeks and try to stay in touch with my striper obsession.

I think it was 2006 when I introduced my new (at the time) fishing partner to this hush-hush winter fishery. We were both in our late 20s and we were as hardcore as you can be about catching stripers. It was later in December and I remember we had a cold start to the winter that year. I took the ride on my Tuesday day off and pulled a skunk. But on Saturday, it was a nice day and my fishing partner, Dave Daluz, expressed some interest in giving it a try. I warned him about the dead bite and the ice creeping in from the edges, but he was unfazed. So we hopped into his Jeep made the drive.

My mind is always running and it’s typically thinking about something related to striper fishing. At the time, my lure of choice at this holdover honey hole was the 3-inch Storm Shad in bunker color, and the recent lack of action had me trying to come up with a way to entice a lethargic striper into taking my little paddle-tailed offering. On and off through the years, I have found that adding a few drops of bunker oil to the belly hole of a wooden plug can sometimes turn on a slow or even completely dead bite. The issue with soft plastics is that there’s nowhere for the oil to collect and therefore it just floats off as soon as it hits the water.

Thinking about the lead weight that’s molded into the body of all swim-shad-style baits, I saw on opportunity. Maybe I could inject bunker oil into the space around the weight? I tried it with the syringe I used for loading Red Fins, but it just clogged the needle, the oil was either too thick or too ‘unrefined’ to pass through such a small hole. The night before, I bought a ‘flavor injector’ at Wal-Mart, which is basically a giant syringe with a huge needle for injecting marinades and sauces into meat. The issue with this thing was that the hole through-which the “marinade” would need to pass was on the side of the needle, and since these shads were so little, there wasn’t much room to jostle this huge needle around without ripping the bait or poking out the other side!

I brought all this gear with me and tried to talk it up with Dave while we drove. He seemed kind of ‘mid’ on the whole idea, but I wasn’t letting it go. We arrived at spot number one and after 30 minutes without a hit, casting over 20 feet of skim ice, I got my injector out and my bunker oil and, after a lot of wrestling with the injector, I did get some oil into the bait. After a few casts, I was still leaving a slick as I dragged the bait across the wet ice and Dave got a little more interested in the concept.

Being the great friend that I am, I grabbed the shad on his line and took on the process of injecting the oil. For some reason, I could not get the oil to come out! I was twisting the needle and muscling the syringe, but it seemed like nothing was coming out! After maybe 10 minutes of almost breaking a sweat trying to inject this tiny shad, I thought, “I’ll pull it out and start over.”

With Dave leaning close to watch, I withdrew the needle and evidently, all of that muscling built up a ton of pressure inside the syringe and a powerful spurt of bunker oil seemed to leap from the needle, leaving an oily zig-zag across the front of Dave’s hoodie! He let out an involuntary groan as he recoiled so quickly away that he almost stumbled over. With a look of pure disgust he said, “Oh GAWD!” and then realized he had no way to wipe this offensive oil off of his shirt! I looked up and saw the squiggle of yellowish liquid drawn from shoulder to shoulder and this grimace of pure disdain scrunching up his face, and I choked on my amusement.

I tried to be stoic about it, but I couldn’t hold it in! And once I started, I couldn’t stop! I kept saying through my hysterical fits, “Dave, I’m sorry, I’m SO sorry!” But I don’t think my hyperventilating laughter helped sell the sincerity of my apology. Eventually, he started to laugh, too and we laughed the whole way home. It was the kind of laughing that leaves you feeling like you did 200 sit-ups the day before!

I guess this proves that a great fishing memory doesn’t have to center around a memorable bite or landmark catch; a good laugh is perhaps even more valuable than a big fish. I say this because, I have been laughing for last hour as I sit here reliving this memory and trying to figure out how to best relay it in writing.

The last laugh of the ordeal came days later, when I saw Dave’s wife at the grocery store and she told me she had to throw the hoodie away because the splatter of bunker oil was still incredibly potent, even after three times through the wash!

Related

One Fish: A 1954 Tog Tale

One Fish: Sharked!

Species Specifics: Shore-Bound Bonito

If you’re looking to catch more bones, stock up on plastic swimmers!