
After reading the article by Charley Soares called “Cuttyhunk Secrets: Lost Art Of The Eel Skin Plug” in the October 2026 edition of The Fisherman, it got me thinking back. A few decades ago, one of my monthly habits was to read Saltwater Sportsman magazine from cover to cover. At the end of the magazine you could then find a series of ads from various companies and charter boat captains. One ad jumped off the page when it advertised Trophy Striped Bass at Cuttyhunk Island, as well as Giant Tarpon in the Key West area by the same charter captain. Since I couldn’t afford a trip to the Florida Keys to troll big plugs for tarpon, I started doing some research about Cuttyhunk Island.
Back in 1602, the explorer Bartholomew Gosnold (1571-1607) visited the island off the Massachusetts coast for 22 days along with 32 members of his crew. Rumor has it he was looking for a source of sassafras as an herbal ingredient. Gosnold also struck up a relationship with the local indigenous population where trading for gold trinkets was common. After that brief stint, he and his crew headed further south to the next island across the sound and named it “Martha” for his daughter…sound familiar? So, almost 20 years before the Pilgrims sailed into Provincetown Harbor on Cape Cod, Gosnold and his crew were exploring Cuttyhunk Island.
The ad I was referring to was for Capt. Bob Smith who fished the waters off Cuttyhunk in his Mackenzie style boat Susan-B. Since my bank account indicated that I could afford a trip to the New Bedford area, we opted for a trip to Cuttyhunk along with a charter with Capt. Smith. This was the first of our two trips to the island.
On our first trip, since the crossing was going to be rough, the skipper made my wife Helen and I sit on the boat’s deck for the almost hour crossing. My back side still feels this crossing on a rainy day. We fished the Sow and Pigs reef for striped bass, and I’m glad that it was at night so we couldn’t see the 8- to 10-foot swells off our stern. That is one rough body of water. Did we catch the 40- to 50-pound bass we had hoped for? Nope, only some 20- to 30-pound stripers, but it was an adventure getting there and fishing with the legendary Capt. Bob Smith.
Our second trip to Cuttyhunk was somewhat different. Instead of taking an hour’s boat ride to the island, we opted to take a float plane from Fair Haven to Cuttyhunk which only took 8 minutes. This trip was scheduled to be a “catch ’em from the beach” type of trip for striped bass. Since there were no Holiday Inn nor Best Western motels on the island, we stayed at the Bosworth House, built in 1888 with five rooms available for guests. The daily rate then for two persons was $34 per night, but if you ate there, the daily rate would drop to $29 per night. Such a bargain, and the fried clams were great.
What was interesting when we visited the island was how certain functions were divided up amongst the various families. One family did the baking, one family ran the post office, one family ran the general store, and two families ran the Bosworth and Allen B&B residences. At least they had electricity in that it first came to Cuttyhunk Island in 1909.
One morning as dawn was peeking over Nashawena Island, I was walking down from the Bosworth House on a paved road towards a nearby rock strewn beach when I heard a “clippy- clopping” noise behind me. Turning around, an estimated 10-point buck almost ran me over as he headed toward the end of the road; why, I don’t know. Back then, only the local residents of the island could hunt deer, so there was an over population of these critters on the island. I can see the local news headlines now, “Visiting Jersey Boy Run Over By Local Trophy Deer.”
Our return trip to the mainland on the float plane was “almost” uneventful, except that the harbor was engulfed with zero visibility fog. As our pilot taxied around the harbor, he noticed a small opening in the fog above, so he yanked the wheel back and almost went straight up to find clear skies. Talk about putting our stomachs in our throats! The rest of the return trip went smooth and uneventful.
Clearly, Cuttyhunk Island has a lot of history. But best of all, it has great memories.