Winter Tautog: A Tale Of Two Tens - The Fisherman

Winter Tautog: A Tale Of Two Tens

author
The author (center) with her biggest blackfish to date, alongside her togging crew with the late Sean Smida (left) and Ray Kerico (right) from Grumpys.

Sometimes you have to go the distance when the tug is the drug.

Fishing, educating, and sharing stories, they’re all true passions of mine. And the one species that has truly hooked me for life is the blackfish.  So much so that it’s been the subject of many past articles here in The Fisherman, as well as my Open Boat episodes and seminars during the winter show season.  Tautog is somewhat sacred to me, and it’s become a favorite to target, to catch, and to study.

Many great memories have been formed from past trips, some near but a lot of them far.   And this particular story, A Tale of Two Tens, is all about going the distance to find those big blackfish.

Although I am based out of the Manasquan inlet region, it’s become somewhat difficult to target blackfish up here. Unfortunately, these wrecks have been hit heavily over the years, many left some devoid of many of the resident blackfish that once inhabited them. Sad but true, this is why I took the initiative to change my fishing habits for them, reflecting on my research obtained in my March, 2024 article in The Fisherman called “Talkin’ Tautog: A Concern For Blackfish?”  Like many other hardcore toggers, I now only keep what I eat, release big breeders, and encourage others to do the same.

tautog and crab
Bait of choice for many winter tautog anglers are white leggers, which the author laughs are “so good the blackfish jump into the totes with them!”

Cape May Winters

Venturing away from Ocean County, I typically head south for the winter and spring, on my way to Cape May which forever has my heart in the offseason; it’s quiet, cold, and this is when the commercial fishery that built this town really shines. Shops like Hands Too Bait and Tackle, party boats, private charters, and marina dock life are very prominent during any season and I always appreciate seeing anglers around when I head south. Gifted with a great fishery, skilled captains, and extensive ground to cover, Cape May is one place every angler should have on their bucket list.

Utsch’s Marina houses three boats owned and operated by three of my favorite captains, Capt. Bob Cope of Full Ahead Sportifshing, Capt. TJ Schwarzwalder of Legal Limit Charters, and of course Capt. Tom Daffin of Fishin’ Fever, current state record holding tautog boat (eclipsing the previous state record caught on the same boat).  These captains will put you on big fish, and you will have an educational experience and entertaining time out on the water.

Usually my crew fishes on the Legal Limit with Capt. TJ so I come prepared with freshly baked cookies, three containers however because Bob and Tom are all big fans of the chocolate chips, a great way to start the day indeed. I would highly recommend all the offerings provided at Utsch’s Marina and its neighboring docks if you are on the hunt for big fish during any season down in Cape May.

When your day has come you never expect it. My day came in January when my OG crew and I ventured out on Legal Limit with the luckiest weather window day you could get that month. Capt. TJ made the run to the infamous Reef Site 11 which spans 0.69 square nautical miles and consists of barges, tires, subway cars, drag drops, military vehicles, and other vessels, creating wonderful structure for our toothy wreck dwellers. As a true lady, I rig fish for my blackfish using a relic, the Super Togger paired with a Daiwa Saltiga 15H built to pull beasts out of the deepest wrecks.

Dropping down fresh white leggers, the bite was very finicky, I could feel a fish rubbing along my line sniffing my crab, this is when patience plays a key part. After what felt like an eternity of feeling this fish it finally got a hook in its mouth and I set hard and pulled it above the buffer zone, then it started digging back down. Being in such deep water I had a battle with my conscience roasting me, “you’re gonna drop this fish.”  Luckily I had Ray Kerico owner of Grumpys Tackle and the late, great Sean Smida next to me coaching me through it. Finally I see her, coming up away from the boat appears a stocky female blackfish.

We promptly netted her, gave her a weigh in at 10 pounds on the nose, took quick pictures and then I torpedo released her back to the deep. I was on cloud nine as this was my second double-digit blackfish, but it wouldn’t be my last.

tautog and sea bass
Capt. TJ Schwarzwalder of Legal Limit Charters with a jumbo black sea bass, another charter and head boat target species this month along the Jersey Coast (12-1/2” minimum, 15 fish bag limit through December 31.)

Double Double

A few drops and fresh crabs passed by then on this drop, my sinker must have hit this blackfish on the head because as soon as I hit the bottom, that non-committal bite I experienced all day changed to a solid chomp and it swam away with my rig. During this hookset and initial fight I was quiet until Sean looked over, saw my face then pointed out the fact that this fish was pulling drag; everyone onboard stopped and watched. After having the subconscious stress of that first fish on and now this one which we all knew was bigger, I felt like what I imagined it might feel like going into labor.

As I gained the upper hand on this battle, this fish also came up away from the boat and from a distance I thought it was a giant cod because all I saw was white belly. Getting this male in the boat was another huge celebration, everyone was cheering for me and I was crying a little. This handsome male blackfish was almost 11 pounds and was released after weighing and photographing.

That moment when I was holding that big male blackfish, Capt. TJ took my picture and I wanted Ray and Sean in it. With big smiles and thumbs up, you could see how proud they are of me because those two have watched me grow into the driven, hell bent angler I have become, representing a prominent female angler in a male-dominated sport, and industry.

That great picture captured a beautiful memory that I hold close to my heart, my favorite trip ever. It captures a day I will never forget with people who I will always respect and appreciate. I now have this picture framed in my room, with the rig and Sean’s memorial fishing token hanging off it, forever cherishing it and continuing to make him proud.

Located at the east end of the Cape May Canal, find these three great captains moored at Utsch’s Marina, 1121 Route 109 in Cape May (Schellenger’s Landing).  It’s just on the other side of the Cape May Canal Bridge, about a mile south of Hands Too Bait and Tackle on your right-hand side, soon after the Garden State Parkway turns to Exit 0, on the way to Cape May.

Related

Knucklebusters: Slinging A Sidewinder

Exploring the traditional angling techniques of using a sidewinder for bottom fishing tautog.

andrew

November Notes: Togging Through Turkey Day

November and tautog go hand in hand, but the eleventh month requires a mix of approaches from New Jersey to Massachusetts.

Inshore: Short Drops, More Tog

Mobility and constant repositioning is key to finding the most productive tog water.